A cutter is the one accessory that can ruin a cigar in half a second: a dull or misaligned blade tears the cap and the wrapper unwraps. What matters is a double blade that meets cleanly and a mouth wide enough for the cigar you actually smoke – our Damascus cutter takes up to a 60 ring gauge. Stainless Damascus also holds an edge far longer than stamped steel, which is why it lasts and looks the part in a gift box. Pairing it with a case? See the cigar gift guide.